Erb’s Palsy & Klumpke’s Palsy

Learn more about the similarities and differences between Erb’s Palsy (waiters tip) and Klumpke’s Palsy (claw hand)

Erb’s Palsy & Klumpke’s Palsy
Photo by Otto Norin / Unsplash

These are brachial plexus injuries seen most commonly in neonates after traumatic delivery, especially shoulder dystocia. They can also occur in adults after trauma.

Erb’s Palsy ("Waiter's Tip" Deformity)

  • Newborn with shoulder dystocia
  • Unable to abduct or flex the arm

Pathophysiology

  • Injury to: Upper trunk of brachial plexus (C5-C6)
    • Musculocutaneous
    • Suprascapular
    • Axillary
  • Caused by: Lateral traction on neck during delivery (e.g., shoulder dystocia), or trauma in adults (e.g., fall on shoulder)

Clinical Presentation

  • Arm is:
    • Adducted (deltoid/supraspinatus weakness)
    • Internally rotated (infraspinatus weakness)
    • Extended at the elbow (biceps weakness)
    • Pronated (biceps/supinator weakness)
  • "Waiter's tip" posture
  • Reflexes: ↓ biceps reflex

Klumpke’s Palsy ("Claw Hand")

Pathophysiology

  • Injury to: Lower trunk of brachial plexus (C8-T1)
    • Ulnar
    • Median (partially)
  • Caused by:
    • Excessive upward traction on the arm during delivery
    • Adult trauma: grabbing a tree branch when falling

Clinical Presentation

  • Claw hand:
    • Hyperextension at MCPs
    • Flexion at IPs
    • More pronounced in the 4th and 5th digits
  • Sensory loss: medial arm/hand (ulnar distribution)
  • Possible Horner syndrome if sympathetic fibers at T1 are involved (ptosis, miosis, anhidrosis)